Artificial Intelligence seems to be everywhere lately. Some articles suggest it will replace large portions of the workforce (which many large corporations are regretting). Others make it sound like a magical assistant capable of running your parish office while you focus on ministry.
The Church has been paying close attention as well. In his recent encyclical Magnifica Humanitas and several public addresses, Pope Leo XIV has emphasized that artificial intelligence is a valuable tool that requires ethical oversight, must serve human dignity and the common good, and should never replace human judgment in matters that affect people's lives. He has repeatedly reminded us that machines are tools, not persons, and that the future of AI depends on the choices human beings make. [vatican.va], [vatican.va], [vaticannews.va]
For Catholic parish staff, that's an important starting point. AI is neither a miracle nor a menace. It is simply a tool, one that can help us communicate, research, organize, and work more efficiently when used wisely.
The truth is much less dramatic than many headlines suggest.
Understanding what AI is, and what it is not, can help your parish use it effectively while avoiding some common pitfalls.
At its best, AI is a highly capable assistant that can help parish staff save time, overcome writer's block, and process information more efficiently.
You might loosely think of AI as the world's fastest intern. It can help generate ideas, organize thoughts, draft content, summarize information, and suggest improvements. It can perform in seconds tasks that might otherwise take you an hour to begin. But it is NOT as good as a great intern and here’s why.
AI functions by accessing the existing base of knowledge on the internet. This knowledge base is likely factual, but what’s on the internet can also be inaccurate or filled with opinions. AI cannot always tell the difference unless you explicitly ask it to. AI simply accesses information and spits it back out to you. And watch out, because it spits it back out in a very authoritative way, but that doesn't mean it is correct.
Here are two examples: Imagine you tell AI: Our parish festival has been held every year since 1950.
If the festival actually started in 1975, AI will likely repeat and build upon the incorrect information. It may confidently produce historical timelines, promotional materials, anniversary celebrations and parishioner communications all based on a false assumption. The AI isn't lying. It's doing exactly what you asked.
Second, you ask for a blurb for the bulletin about the $3,000 charitable donation tax write off available this year. It will confidently draft you a blurb about this for your bulletin. But, guess what? If you are wrong about that $3,000, or the tax law has changed, it will not tell you so.
Why not? The biggest misconception about AI is that it "thinks." It doesn't.
AI generates responses by identifying patterns in vast amounts of existing information. It can sometimes combine existing ideas in new ways, but it doesn't reason, imagine, or experience the world as a human being does. Every answer it gives is built from information it was trained on and the exact instructions or prompt you provide.
This is why AI can sometimes sound remarkably intelligent while still being wrong.
Imagine you tell AI: Our parish festival has been held every year since 1950.
If the festival actually started in 1975, AI will likely repeat and build upon the incorrect information. It may confidently produce historical timelines, promotional materials, anniversary celebrations and parishioner communications all based on a false assumption. The AI isn't lying. It's doing exactly what you asked.
AI also doesn't understand which facts matter most. It doesn't know your parish, your community, or your intentions unless you provide that context.
While AI can help generate ideas and identify connections, it cannot independently develop wisdom, judgment, or truly original insights. Meaningful analysis requires human direction, multiple prompts, and careful review of the results.
Bottom line: today's publicly available AI is not comparable to human intelligence. It is a powerful assistant, but it still requires a human driver to provide context, evaluate outputs, verify facts, and make decisions.
AI doesn’t know your parish and AI ONLY does what you tell it to do. Nothing more (at least not consistently).
Everything you type into your AI assistant is accessible to the major corporations that own these tools. It is no longer your information to own. These corporations will use all of your questions and AI’s answer to build a more profitable tool for themselves as well as to give other users answers to their questions.
Protect yourself and your parishioners by only giving out information you’d give to someone who walks in your parish office. No names, contact info, giving history or other things like that. If you’re hoping for donation analysis to fuel fundraising efforts do so with ID numbers assigned to each donor’s giving history so that you can let AI analyze without sacrificing personally identifiable information.
The average query answered by AI takes about a water bottle’s worth of water to cool the data center’s that are required to operate the AI. There are plenty of energy and other implications from AI data centers as well. I am no expert on the environmental impacts so I’ll simply point you to some related articles, but I do find it helpful to think about that as I choose how many questions to ask my AI every week.
AI does often suggest the next step you can take after it answers your prompt. In theory this is helpful. It might suggest it draft you a social post to promote an event after you just made an event poster. But watch out for this. If you keep saying “yes” to it’s suggestions, you’re allowing AI to drive you, rather than you drive it.
There are a lot of negatives here so far, so you might be asking, should I really be using AI? I will leave that ethical decision to you personally, but here’s what I can tell you: What AI is good and how it can help your parish.
Not sure how to promote your Advent mission? Ask AI: Give me 10 ideas for promoting an Advent parish mission to young families.
Need fresh ideas for stewardship month? Ask AI: Suggest themes, bulletin content, and social media ideas for Catholic stewardship month.
Need an overview of planned giving, church accessibility, or volunteer recruitment trends?
AI can quickly explain concepts, identify common questions, and point you toward relevant resources.
However, AI should help start your research, not replace it.
Suppose you need a bulletin article, a grant application, an event description, a thank-you letter or a social media post. AI can generate a solid starting point in seconds.
For example: Draft a 300-word bulletin article encouraging participation in our parish picnic.
You may not use the draft exactly as written, but it's often easier to edit an imperfect draft than to create something from scratch.
Good prompt: Explain donor-advised funds and cite your sources.
Better prompt: Explain donor-advised funds, provide links to your sources, and distinguish between facts and opinions.
Always ask where the information came from.
This may be the most important rule in this article. Never assume AI's sources are accurate simply because they appear professional. Open the links. Read the source material. Confirm that the source actually says what AI claims it says.
Before sending an important communication, ask: Review this article and identify any factual claims that should be verified. Or ask: What statements in this document may require source verification?
This won't catch everything, but it can help identify potential issues.
Many users stop after generating a first draft.
Another approach that can be helpful is to give it your near final draft and say prompts like: Edit this article for clarity and professionalism. Explain each major change you make and why you are recommending it.
This turns AI into a writing coach instead of merely a content generator.
Parish Staff Member:
We are launching a capital campaign to improve accessibility. Give me three themes for the campaign.
AI:
Parish Staff Member: Expand "Welcoming Every Generation" into a case statement for a Catholic parish.
AI: Creates first draft.
Parish Staff Member: Rewrite this for parishioners over age 60.
AI: Creates revised version.
Parish Staff Member: What factual claims in this document should be verified?
AI: Identifies project dates, construction costs, accessibility statistics, and campaign goals.
Parish Staff Member: Edit the final version and explain every major suggestion.
AI: Improves clarity while providing rationale.
Notice something important:
The human does.
AI should never replace relationships, ministry, discernment, or pastoral care.
It can, however, reduce administrative burdens and help parish staff spend less time staring at blank screens and more time serving people.
Used responsibly, AI can help parish teams communicate more effectively, draft content more efficiently, and support the mission of the Church.
The key is remembering that AI is neither magical nor dangerous. It is simply a tool.
Like any tool, its value depends on how wisely it is used.
Tell us how your parish is using AI or what concerns you have. We’ll include your story in a follow up article! ewilliams@catholicfsmn.org
Why this topic? Economic strain on families and workers and the future implications of artificial intelligence was surfaced by interviewees in our 2025 diocesan listening exercise across Southern Minnesota. The Catholic Foundation Board has selected this as one of our strategic priorities in order to support and empower our local communities. Visit our FY27-FY30 strategic plan page to learn more.